“Beastly improvident little worm! The good book hath it, you may turn. Turn all you like, but next time think, and don’t turn up in someone’s sink”!
~ Mossy Powell, 22nd October, 1935
Mossy Powell wrote this when explorations were drawn to a halt at Wookey Hole after a local resident found a worm in her sink. The Log of the Wookey Hole Exploration Expedition (1935) explains further:
“Curiously enough, the order to cease diving was occasioned by nothing more or less than a worm! What little things can alter the course of great undertakings! This little blitherer did; it appeared in an old lady’s sink, way down the village, on Sunday morning, and instead of asking it where it came from, and whether it had been making a night out, and was cooling it’s head prior to returning home, or if it had merely fallen out of her own Sunday cabbages, she blamed it’s sudden appearance on the wretched divers and seizing it by the scruff of it’s neck, she madly waived it in the air, making the welkin ring with her outcry against befouled drinking water”.
This narrative from the Cave Diving Group archives is reproduced here to demonstrate just how delicate cave access agreements can be!
Negotiating access to caves can be a drawn out and delicate process.
Some people have some misconceptions about access to UK cave diving sites. Putting aside the confusion and debates regarding the Countryside Rights of Way Act & designated Access Land, let us instead consider the more common situation of visiting caves.
Traditionally, UK cave divers (i.e. those who dive in UK caves) have had a dry caving background. Cave diving was seen as a tool, amongst other specialisms, to further cave exploration. As such, cave divers had spent years understanding cave access as part of their dry caving background. These cavers are often most active in their home area, so build up personal relationships with farmers, landowners, and other cavers and so understand any access issues relevant to particular sites. In recent years, interest in cave diving has grown amongst those with a diving, rather than caving background. As such they may have no knowledge or understanding that access is a privilege rather than a right, and needs working at to achieve.
Recently, this interest has prompted the publication of guide books which include UK inland sites (as opposed to sea caves). Publication in a book, on the internet, or anywhere else should not be regarded as indication that any site can be visited. Access agreements do change (sometimes with landowner changes) so any information on access, particularly in print should be regarded as potentially inaccurate or out of date.
The CDG publishes regional ‘Sump Indexes’ periodically. These are the definitive reference work, to be used in conjunction with ‘dry’ cave reference works. They list all sites of speleological interest, not just those easily accessible resurgences which cave divers can access without dry caving (of which there are but a handful in the UK). The CDG also has an online web forum as part of this web site; this is open to non-members so enquiries could be made there, where locally active CDG members can offer information and advice.
Nearly all caves in the UK are situated on privately owned land. Many landowners are content to allow cavers unrestricted access to caves on their land – they do not even require the cavers to visit their homes/ farms to politely request permission to visit the cave. Some landowners like to be asked, but will willingly grant permission. Others require payment of a ‘goodwill fee’ to cross their land to the cave – this could be considered recompense for ‘wear and tear’ to the land/ grass and/ or fences/ stiles/ gates. Another group of landowners are the show cave owners – who make a living out of tourists wanting to see their caves. There may thus be conditions attached to visits by cavers, such as the times they enter and exit to avoid them coming into contact with the tourist parties, and the cavers may be expected to pay the same fee as the tourists – after all, the show cave is operating a business….
Then there are caves which have an access agreement imposed on them. These are frequently negotiated between the landowner and a caver management team. These teams are volunteers from within the caving community, who organise and operate an access system on behalf of a landowner; this is often a response to historical access difficulties, and at the request of the landowner who may not want to administer a system themselves. Cavers may be required to arrange a permit to visit the cave and display this in car windscreens, etc. The cave may be gated, which requires the cavers to obtain a key to gain access.
Another consideration might be caves which are Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) which are determined in law and have restrictions imposed to protect them from damage – be it to flora, fauna or the cave itself.
Finally, there are landowners who simply do not want cavers on their land – full stop. At the end of the day, a landowner may simply wish to have privacy on his land, which is their right.
Cavers are expected to respect access in each of the cases above. Failing to do so may result in worsening of relations with the landowners and the closure of access to the caves – to everyone’s detriment. Landowners have the legal right to refuse access to caves, even on “Access Land” as defined by the CRoW Act.